The influence of religion on philosophy. I religion and philosophy in ancient greece

The ancient philosophy of ancient Greece is an extensive historical and cultural layer of teachings, philosophical schools, which together had a great influence on the spiritual, ideological development of scientific subsequent generations of scientists and philosophers. Together with ancient Roman philosophy, they constitute an invaluable cultural achievement, which is rightly considered to be the basis of modern European civilization.

The first prerequisites for the emergence of ancient Greek philosophy appeared in the 7th-6th centuries BC, but they acquired a more mature design by the second half of the 5th BC. During this period, physical and mental labor, as well as such occupations as agriculture and handicrafts, were separately singled out. In addition, there is a cultural, economic flourishing, called the city-state, which was a stronghold of the collective and individual life of citizens in absolutely all its manifestations.

Undoubtedly, the emergence, formation and development of philosophy in ancient Greece was closely associated with the growth of scientific knowledge and discoveries. From the divine knowledge of the world, man strove to explain and study the occurring phenomena of nature through the prism of the logical, rational. Despite the fact that philosophy in its original form still strongly intersected with worldly experience and wisdom, its main purpose was to obtain knowledge about the origin of the world and man himself, and most importantly, to determine the place of man in this vast world.

Stages of formation of Greek philosophy

The history of the origin and formation of the philosophy of ancient Greece from different points of view is divided into three or four periods. The first two stages seem to be the most valuable.

The first period covers the time of the 7th - 5th centuries BC. In modern literature, this period is usually called pre-Socratic. The philosophy of the first stage was based on the teachings of Thales and his followers - Anaximander and Anaximenes. Thales put forward the first assumptions about the relativity of the structure of the world, was the founder of mathematics and a number of other sciences. Anaximander tried to establish what is the primary matter, Anaximenes believed that air is the source of all things. Representatives of the slave-owning aristocracy, entering into confrontation with such scientific trends, founded their own direction - philosophical idealism. Its first representative was Pythagoras.


Classical Philosophy of Ancient Greece constitutes the second stage of the origin of ancient Greek philosophy and includes the time between the 5th - 4th centuries BC. The most prominent philosophers of this period are Socrates, Aristotle and Plato. In ancient Greece, the development and influence of materialistic philosophy is intensifying, in addition, journalism and political theories arise, which was the result of a fierce class struggle in ancient state. Plato presented ideas as the basis of being, which were given a key place in the world of things, since it was ideas that could exist forever. Aristotle, in contrast to him, called matter the basis of all being, and a certain reason lay at the basis of each phenomenon. put forward the idea that it is quite possible to give a positive answer to the question of the criteria of truth. Truth is born in a dispute - a theory that Socrates created and came to the conclusion that a person who defends his point of view in a dispute imperceptibly inspires his opponent with its meaning.

The life and work of the sophist philosophers gave impetus to the continuation and development of philosophical movements and schools. At the end of the period under review, a trend such as natural philosophy of ancient Greece. The main idea of ​​natural philosophy of the ancient Greek world is a guideline for the interpretation of the studied concepts and phenomena about nature, opposing them to the teachings about man.

Similarities and differences between philosophy and religion

The origin of philosophy, its relationship with religion in Ancient Greece and the Ancient East

Philosophy appeared when religion already existed and was an integral part of the worldview ancient man. This led to the fact that philosophy, although sometimes skeptical about the interpretation of the divine, nevertheless developed in an inseparable connection with God and actively used religious ideas. Religious ideas, clothed in a mythical form, were transferred to Greece from the East. They entered Greek religion, and only from there did philosophy take advantage of them.

In antiquity scientific activity has always been conceived within the framework and limits of the religious worldview, but the ancient Greek religion did not prevent the free development of scientific thinking. The Greek religion did not have a theological systematization and arose on the basis of a free agreement on the subject of faith. In the proper sense of the word, in Greece there was no universally recognized religious doctrine but only mythology” Drach G.V. Birth ancient philosophy and the beginning of anthropological problems. - Rostov n / a: Phoenix, 2001. , p. eighteen.

But the ancient religious ideas were not the end in themselves of philosophy. “They were subject to transformation and subordination in order to substantiate rational socio-ethical normativity. The representative of this normativity was “physis”, which brings together the unit of gods, people and nature into a single unit that is subject to rational justification. And the rational substantiation of human life required the involvement of a huge theocosmogonic material, and empirical knowledge, and deductive sciences” Drach G.V. The birth of ancient philosophy and the beginning of anthropological problems. - Rostov n / a: Phoenix, 2001. , p. 305.

The period of intensive collection of information in various fields of knowledge was characterized by the emergence of the Milesian school, within which rationalistic ideas about the world are created and developed. The Milesians for the first time raise questions about the origin and structure of the world in a form that requires a clear and understandable answer. This was manifested in the rejection of traditional religion (religious skepticism about the relationship between gods and people, etc.). The Milesian school for the first time abolished the mythological picture of the world, based on the opposition of the heavenly (divine) to the earthly (human), and introduced the universality of physical laws.

This tradition causes a reaction, which manifested itself, in particular, among the Pythagoreans. Its essence is to protect the sphere of traditional authorities. “This new attitude towards wisdom is called philosophy and includes a pious attitude towards tradition. At the same time, rationalistic concepts are deprived of their destructive power and get their place, which consists in the pedagogical process, which includes the formation of a public pious attitude of a person to the world and the deity. Philosophical and religious origins of science / ed. P.P. Gaidenko - M.: Martis, 1997., p. 42.

The Pythagoreans were considered the first philosophers, and at the same time they represented a religious union. “The original core of Pythagoreanism is religious. It was composed of an archaic layer, which in its essence is older than Pythagoreanism and was only assimilated by the latter, and some innovations introduced by the founder of the Pythagorean religion” Presocratics. - Minsk: Harvest, 1999. , p. 133. The goal to which a person should strive, according to their ideas, is likening to God, and the development of the divine element in oneself occurs through understanding the structure of the divine cosmos, which is possible through philosophy.

Although some sophists, such as Protagoras and Critias, believed that God and religion were fiction, subsequent philosophers harmoniously combined philosophy and the religious picture of the world, without opposing them to each other. A striking example of such a combination was the metaphysics (first philosophy, or theology) of Aristotle, which was later adopted by medieval theologians. Since Aristotle allows two types of entities - natural and supernatural (divine), then the sciences that study these entities will be physics and metaphysics Savitskaya T.V. Philosophy and religion: intersection points and demarcation of I // Vestnik KRAUNTS. Humanitarian sciences. 2010. №2. P.86.. Aristotle also included logic in the first philosophy, thereby creating the opportunity to use philosophy in the future to explain religious postulates.

The philosophical teachings of the West in the era of the Ancient World did not turn into any of the world religions or at least widespread in Ancient Greece and Rome.

Eastern philosophy developed in close interaction with religion: often one and the same philosophical current appears both as a philosophy proper and as a religion.

Unlike Greece, in India and China, the transition from mythology to philosophy was carried out “on the basis of a strongly formed and extremely rooted ritual. The inviolability of the authority of the ritual, its defining role in the genesis of Indian and Chinese philosophical thought, rigidly determined the boundaries of philosophical discourse. If mythology allowed for the multivariance of world models, which opened up the possibility of a variety of discourse, methods of theorizing, then the ritual severely limited such variability, firmly tying reflection to tradition” Ibid., pp. 86-87.

The first evidence of an independent systematic exposition of Indian philosophy was the sutras. In India, numerous philosophical schools in one way or another correlated mainly with Brahmanism and Buddhism. The division into separate schools in India did not lead to official recognition of the priority of any one of the philosophical directions. Until modern times, Indian philosophy practically developed exclusively in line with the six classical systems, guided by the authority of the Vedas and unorthodox currents.

Reason, rational in man and his thinking was placed on top of Confucianism. Feelings and emotions in a person were greatly belittled. But Confucianism, despite this, was the main and leading form of religion, although the problems of religion as such (if we have in mind its metaphysics and mysticism) Confucianism was very cool, sometimes even negatively.

Along with Confucianism, Taoism was the most influential in the 100 Schools rivalry. "The original philosophical theory of Taoism and numerous folk beliefs and superstitions, magic and mantic had almost nothing in common with each other." But over time, a synthesis of these two sides took place in Taoism: the search for immortality and folk beliefs and rituals, “which had previously existed and developed purely empirically, which needed support and “theoretical” justification and reinforcement” Savitskaya T. V. Philosophy and religion: intersection points and demarcation I // Vestnik KRAUNC. Humanitarian sciences. 2010. №2. P.87..

In China, Confucianism in the 2nd century B.C. achieved the official status of the state ideology, managing to maintain it until the beginning of the 20th century. Thus, in China, religion was subordinated to those traditions and norms that were canonized by Confucianism.

philosophy religion similarity difference

History of aesthetic thought from ancient times to antiquity

The ancient Greeks had lively connections with the East. There is nothing surprising that they widely used the scientific and artistic and aesthetic experience of the Eastern peoples. Ancient Greek philosophy, aesthetics...

The ideological nature of philosophy

Philosophy and religion have completely different tasks and essence, essentially different forms of spiritual activity. Religion is life in communion with God, aimed at satisfying the personal need of the human soul for salvation...

Natural Philosophy of Ancient Greece

The basis of ancient Greek philosophy was: mythology, pre-philosophy, proto-science, the teachings of the Orphics, lyric poetry ...

Basic questions of philosophy

The commonality between morality, morality, and law lies in the fact that these forms of social consciousness carry prescriptive knowledge, i.e. prescriptive normative knowledge, and formulate a certain model of human behavior ...

The main directions of ancient philosophy

One can classify the schools of the early Greek philosophers in various ways. The division into dialecticians and metaphysicians is very conditional and presupposes a modern understanding of the terms. It does not reflect all the depths of the contradictions of ancient philosophy...

The concept of love in philosophy

What does a person think about love? Does he value his body? Does he perceive it as a sacred vessel or as a container of vile lusts? Does he feel the universality of Eros or does he know only one facet of it? For example...

Statehood in Ancient Greece arises at the beginning of the 1st millennium BC. e. in the form of independent and independent policies - separate city-states, which included, along with the urban territory, also adjacent rural settlements ...

Ideas about morality, politics and law in ancient Greek philosophy

On the territory of the Peloponnesian peninsula in the beginning. I millennium BC states arose in the form of policies (city-states) ...

The problem of interconnection and demarcation of religion and philosophy

Philosophy appeared when religion already existed and was an integral part of the worldview of ancient man. This led to the fact that philosophy, although sometimes skeptical about the interpretation of the divine ...

Correlation between philosophy and worldview. The problem of being in the philosophy of ancient Greece

Ordinary thinking perceives the terms "to be", "to exist", "to be in cash" as synonyms, i.e. close in meaning. Philosophy used the terms "to be", "being" to denote not just existence, but that ...

The formation of philosophy

High level The development of ancient Greek society and its culture is explained by many factors. A convenient geographical position provided the possibility of establishing maritime communications with close and distant countries (Egypt, India) ...

Philosophy in the ancient world

Greek philosophy arose in the 7th - 6th centuries. BC, during the period of development and strengthening of the slave system, when society was divided into slave owners and slaves, rich and poor, full and powerless ...

Philosophy of Ancient Greece

Formation period. The first elements of philosophical thinking appeared already in the works of ancient Greek historians - Homer, Herodotus, Hesioid and Thucydides. They raised and comprehended questions about the origin of the world and its development...

Philosophical concepts of law in ancient culture

Characteristics of ancient philosophy

Antiquity is that milestone in the history of the development of mankind, at which philosophy arises almost simultaneously in three centers of ancient civilization - in China, India and Greece ...

Religion of the Hellenistic era

Although it is difficult, as has already been said, to trace the historical development of Greek religion on direct facts, changes in it are still clearly noticeable towards the end of the classical era and in the Hellenistic and Roman eras. The first of these was the spread of foreign and mixed cults. Some Eastern deities penetrated into Greece, as we know, even in the early era, but then they were completely Hellenized. Now, especially in the Hellenistic-Roman period, a number of purely Eastern cults take root in Greece: the cults of the Egyptian deities - Isis and Ammon, the Asiatic ones - Attis, Adonis, the "Syrian goddess", etc. The cult of the new syncretic Greek-Egyptian introduced by the Ptolemies was very popular god Serapis. about that Greek-barbarian cultural mutual influence, which is so typical of the Hellenistic era, the Greek element was more active in the field of science, art, literature, language, while in the field of religion, on the contrary, it was in. waste elements more influenced Greece. This is explained by the whole appearance of that decadent era with its inclination towards mysticism, which just permeated the Eastern religions.

Eastern influence also affected the deification of the Hellenistic kings. In Greece itself, where democratic and rationalist traditions were still too strong, this cult of kings did not find any ground for itself. Attempts to introduce the cult of Alexander the Great during his lifetime caused an ironic attitude in Greece. "If Alexander wants to be a god, then let him be a god," the Spartans said on this occasion. However, the spirit of the era gradually affected the Greeks. Demetrius Poliorketos, as the liberator of Greece, was given divine honors. In the Hellenistic East, the kings (Ptolemies, Seleucids, etc.) were equated directly with the gods.

The influence of religion on philosophy

Religion and mythology had a profound influence on the art, literature, and philosophy of ancient Greece. Religious and mythological plots and motifs in literature and art have already been mentioned. In philosophy, the influence of religion was especially evident in the early era. The Ionian natural philosophers noticeably reflect mythological ideas: for example, the idea of ​​Thales of Miletus that the world originated from water is still not far from the myth of the Ocean as the father of everything that exists. Later idealist philosophers, up to Socrates and Plato, often used mythological images to present their concepts. The influence of religion on philosophy increased again in the Hellenistic-Roman era, when, in connection with the decline of ancient democracy, religious and philosophical systems began to emerge, such as Neoplatonism, Neopythagoreanism.

freethinking

But in philosophy, the opposite, atheistic worldview of ancient Greece was expressed with the greatest force. In this country, with the same right, one can see the birthplace of free thought, with which we consider it the cradle of science, literature, and art.

Already in Homer a very free-thinking attitude to the myths about the gods appears. It is impossible not to notice in the Homeric poems a characteristic duality in relation to religious ideas. Characters poems - Achilles, Agamemnon, Priam, Hector, Odysseus and others - are full of deep, purely religious reverence for the gods; in their actions and speeches one cannot find a trace of disrespect, much less ridicule of them. On the contrary, the author of the poem himself, speaking on his own behalf about the gods, about their properties and actions, shows very little religious feeling. He freely, and sometimes, as it were, with gusto talks about the bad and funny sides of the nature of the gods, about their unjust enmity towards certain people or peoples, about cruelty, slyness, mutual deceit and cunning; speaks of the inexorable hostility of Hera to the Trojans, Poseidon to Odysseus; even speaks of the weakness and impotence of the gods in front of people (for example, the victory of Diomedes over Aphrodite and Ares in battle); talking about their love affairs. What is already one more than frivolous short story about how the deceived husband Hephaestus caught his wife Aphrodite and her lover Ares at the crime scene and, having covered both with a net, exposed them to ridicule of all the gods. All these stories do not at all testify to the special religiosity of the author (or authors) of the poems. No wonder the devout Greeks considered Homer almost an atheist, and Plato, in his ideal state, proposed to ban the reading of Homer for his immorality. Obviously, in those circles of the tribal aristocracy, for which poems were composed and sung, already in the 9th-8th centuries. BC. there was a critical attitude towards the gods and myths about them.

A deeper freethinking developed in the classical period. The tragedy of Aeschylus "Chained Prometheus", where, in contrast to the noble friend of people Prometheus, Zeus is portrayed as a cruel and unjust tyrant, was a work essentially anti-religious. In the words of Marx, the gods of Greece were "mortally wounded" by this tragedy. In the tragedies of Euripides, the gods are also presented from a very unattractive side: Hera, Apollo, Aphrodite and other gods destroy innocent people either out of hatred for them, or out of base motives. Euripides even goes so far as to deny the existence of the gods. So, for example, in the tragedy "Bellerfont" her hero flies up to heaven to find out if there are gods there; seeing on earth the kingdom of violence and untruth, he believes that there are no gods at all and that everything that is told about them is empty fairy tales.

Freethinking manifested itself most fully in philosophy. Already early philosophical systems were essentially a negation of religion. Ionian natural philosophers saw the basis and beginning of the world in eternally moving matter (water, air, fire). The Eleatics, with their doctrine of eternity and the infinity of being, also acted as representatives of the rational concept of the universe as opposed to the religious and mythological one. Xenophanes, the founder of this school, ridiculed anthropomorphic ideas about the gods; however, he believed in a deity, one and unlike people. Empedocles developed the naive materialistic doctrine of the four elements and gave the first outline of the evolutionary theory of the origin of organisms. The atomistic theory of the universe of Anaxagoras (material "seeds of things" as the basis of the world) was further developed by the materialists Leucippus and Democritus. The same Anaxagoras taught that the sun is a huge red-hot mass, and not a god. For his godlessness, Anaxagoras was expelled from Athens, and his writings were burned. The Sophists, led by Protagoras and Gorgias, with their relativistic theory of knowledge ("Man is the measure of all things") also undermined the foundations of the religious worldview. The great Aristotle dealt an even stronger blow to religion with his largely materialistic, albeit inconsistent, system. In the Hellenistic era, the school of Epicurus, continuing best traditions classical materialism, gave it a more finished form. The gods of Epicurus, although they were not completely destroyed, were expelled from the world into "inter-world spaces" and removed from participation in the affairs of people. Finally, the largest satirist of antiquity, Lucian of Samosata (2nd century AD), mercilessly ridiculed the gods, clearly presenting all the absurdity of the mythological stories about them ("Charon", "Conversations of the Gods", "Meeting of the Gods", "Sea Conversations", "Conversations in the realm of the dead, etc.). According to Marx, the Greek gods, already wounded: to death by the tragedies of Aeschylus, "had to die once again - in a comic form - in the "Conversations" of Lucian."

Yet the Greek religion survived until the victory of Christianity in the Roman Empire. Some of its features have merged into Christianity.

RELIGION AND PHILOSOPHY IN ANCIENT GREECE

In ancient Greece, religion was not in a struggle with science, in the modern sense of the latter word, that is, with the totality of positive knowledge obtained by people; but religion then collided with philosophy, which included all attempts to rationally interpret both the phenomenon of dead and living nature and traditional human beliefs.

Philosophy was largely a product of religion itself.

This latter in ancient Greece did not have an organized priesthood at its disposal. Therefore, it was not expressed in fixed and binding dogmas. She did not prescribe anything except rituals, certain external actions that were part of the everyday life of a citizen. At the same time, it was rich in legends, myths that captivated the imagination, instructed the mind, and at the same time provoked reflection. Where did these legends come from? No doubt the source of them was considered forgotten divine revelations; but religious legends branched out so capriciously, were so diverse, so mobile, and in many cases were so contradictory, infantile, shocking and absurd, that it was impossible not to see in them, along with the divine revelation, the work of human hands. It would be a futile endeavor to attempt to separate the original content from later accidental accretions in myths. Moreover, the Greek, an artist by nature, consciously plays with his object, even when it comes to the gods; he neglects the exact meaning of the stories he tells. On the other hand, these gods, who, according to legend, communicated the beginnings of sacred legends to man, are themselves imperfect and limited: they themselves have not gone far from man. In this way philosophy could develop very freely in the depths and under the protection of popular mythology itself.

Philosophy begins, of course, by disowning and attacking its nurse. “People created gods,” says Xenophanes, “to the gods they communicated their own appearance, their feelings, their language. If the bulls could draw, they would give their gods the look of a bull. Homer and Hesiod attributed to the gods everything that people have shameful and criminal. The luminaries, Anaxagoras declares, are not at all the essence of a deity: they are red-hot masses, in their nature exactly the same as earthly stones. Some sophists mock the gods themselves. “I have no desire to investigate whether the gods exist or not,” said Protagoras, “many things hinder me in this, namely the darkness of the subject and the brevity of human life.”

This is how philosophy grew, opposing religious beliefs, rising above them, or treating them with complete indifference; spiritually it was independent, it was free even in the political sense, for if some philosophers were persecuted, it was only for certain details of their teachings, which seemed hostile to popular religion.

This development of philosophy was nothing but the development of the intellect and reason of man; and thinkers so passionately believed in reason that they dreamed of creating from it the basic principle of man and the universe.

The task that the mind sets itself from this moment on is to prove to itself its reality and its power in the face of the blind necessity of the cosmic flow of phenomena, in the face of chance, indifferent to everything, which, apparently, is the only law of the world.

In this work, he was inspired by the consideration of art, where the artist's thought collides with matter alien to it, without which it could not be realized ... This matter has its own form, its own laws, its own aspirations; it is indifferent or even hostile to the idea that it should express according to the artist's intention. And yet the artist conquers her; moreover, he makes her wear an artificial form with the greatest flexibility and grace. Now it already seems that marble itself strives to depict Pallas or Apollo, that the sculptor has only released these potentialities hidden in it.

And isn't the mind in a similar position in the face of blind necessity, Ananke? According to Plato, according to Aristotle, “Ananke”, rough matter, is basically not hostile to reason and measure. The more carefully the nature of mind and matter is studied, the more obvious becomes their mutual closeness, connection, unity. Aristotle shows that in matter, at first glance, completely chaotic, there is already a form. Matter in essence is nothing but a potential form. So the mind exists and has real power, because without it nothing could remain in its given form, but everything would return to chaos. We groan under the blows of cruel fate, we complain about the misfortunes and fragility of our lives, and in this we are right; but chaos is only one side of things; he who examines them in the light of reason discovers reason in themselves.

The Greek philosophers strove to represent as high as possible, as powerful as possible, this mind, whose role in nature was defined by them in the sense indicated above. And the more they were inspired by it, the more reason, in comparison with beings involved in matter and death, seemed to be the kind of being that par excellence deserves the predicate "divine", squandered at random by popular religion. All nature is suspended from reason, but all nature is not able to equal it, Aristotle said, and having shown the existence of thought in itself, the existence of a perfect mind, he called this mind God. So, if the mind turned away from traditional religion, then only in order to found on the soil of the very knowledge of nature a new, truer religion.

It should also be noted that in the view of the Greeks, God-reason is not an abstraction or abstract reasoning. It is the power of nature, it is the king who governs all things. It is to him that the name "Zeus" should belong. “This whole universe, revolving in the heavens, says the old man Cleans, turning to Zeus, moves by itself where you direct it. Your hand holding the lightning subdues all things, both the smallest and the largest, to the universal mind. Nothing is done anywhere without you—nothing, except for the deeds done by villains in their madness. But you can make an even number out of an odd number; you turn discord into harmony; under your gaze, hatred becomes friendship. God, you who command behind the clouds. thunder, draw the people out of their gloomy ignorance! Father, drive away the clouds that darken their souls! And make them partakers of that reason by which you so justly govern all things, that we may give you honor for honor, tirelessly glorifying your deeds, as befits mortals. For neither for mortals nor for the gods is there a higher lot than to eternally glorify the universal law with worthy words.

Such is philosophical religion. Is it not an irreconcilable enemy of popular religion? does not the whole content of these myths, sanctified by long-term worship, represent in its chapters a continuous fantasy, confusion and chaos? The people deified the heavenly bodies. But aren't the luminaries in their ideally correct movements a direct manifestation of the law, that is, the mind, God? The people revere Jupiter as a gift of gods and people. Isn't this belief hiding a presentiment of that connection that connects all parts of the universe to each other, forming from them, as it were, a single body subordinate to a common soul? Religion prescribes respect for the laws, fidelity to duty, reverence for the dead; it indicates the support of human weakness in the gods-providers. Is she not also in this case the interpreter and helper of reason? The mind that is true god, does not represent anything absolutely inaccessible to a person: a person is involved in it. So, religious beliefs can be of human origin and at the same time be worthy of respect. The task of philosophy is to deepen the hidden connection between traditional doctrines and the universal mind and to support in these doctrines everything that contains a grain of truth.

Such is the way in which philosophy came little by little to reconciliation with religion. Already Plato and Aristotle accept the traditional belief in the divinity of the sky and celestial bodies and generally look for traces and germs of philosophical thought in myths.

Among the Stoics, reason, taking on a pantheistic character, becomes the main part of the human soul and at the same time the main beginning and ultimate goal of all things; in this form it is inevitably present in all naturally born human beliefs, in everything that teaches people to rise above their personal opinions and passions. Of course, myths, legends, religious rites deserve nothing but contempt, because they reduce the gods to the level of man or even lower. But at the basis of these narratives, if we can understand them, if we reveal their allegorical meaning under their literal meaning, we will find the truth. Zeus is the image of God, for with his unity and his omnipotence he binds all things together; minor gods are symbols of divine potentialities, which are manifested in the multiplicity and variety of elements, in the products of the earth, in great people, benefactors of mankind. The same Zeus, depending on which side we consider him, turns out to be either Hermes, or Dionysus, or Hercules. Hercules is power, Hermes is divine knowledge. The cult of Hercules is the veneration of effort, effort, directness, and contempt for cowardice and voluptuousness. Carried away on this path, the Stoics could not stop, and their fantasy on the basis of the allegorical interpretation of myths knew no measure. They were carried away by the desire to save as much as possible of the popular beliefs and rituals, believing that reason, since it should have power not only for the elect, but for all people, should be clothed in various forms, corresponding different levels people development.

The last remarkable manifestation of the philosophical spirit of the Greeks was Neoplatonism, which, while discussing the essence of reason, wanted to rise above reason itself in its doctrine of the infinite unity. But the more transcendent the Neoplatonic deity became in relation to things, in relation to life and thought itself, the more strongly did the Neoplatonists feel the need to introduce a hierarchy of intermediate beings between the lower and higher forms of being. This intermediate layer just coincided with the area of ​​folk-religious ideas. The gods of folk religion, close to human weaknesses, extend a helping hand to us in order to raise us to the supreme god. And Plotinus, as well as his student Porfiry, little by little justify from the point of view of reason all the elements of traditional religion: myths, sacred traditions, the cult of St. images, prayer, sacrifice, sorcery. As symbols inserted between what is perceived by the senses and what is accessible only to the mind, all these things are good and true, for they are necessary in order to turn people to the immaterial and ineffable.

From the book Philosophy author Lavrinenko Vladimir Nikolaevich

2. The problem of man in the philosophy of Ancient Greece Ancient Greece marked the beginning of the Western European philosophical tradition in general and philosophical anthropology in particular. In ancient Greek philosophy, initially a person does not exist on his own, but only in a system

From the book Philosophy: A Textbook for Universities author Mironov Vladimir Vasilievich

1. The Genesis of Philosophy in Ancient Greece Philosophy has its own special approach to the subject, which distinguishes it both from the everyday-practical and from the natural-scientific approach to the world. Just as a mathematician asks what a unit is and gives a rather complicated definition

From the book The Knight and the Bourgeois [Studies in the History of Morals] author Ossovskaya Maria

CHAPTER II THE KNIGHT ETHOS IN ANCIENT GREECE In this chapter we want to reconstruct the ethos of the knightly elite, an ethos that in its further development characterizes not only a warrior, but also a man of peacetime, who considers himself entitled to occupy the highest levels of social life.

From the book A Brief Outline of the History of Philosophy the author Iovchuk M T

§ 1. Philosophy in ancient India The emergence of philosophy in ancient India dates back approximately to the middle of the first millennium BC. e., when states began to form on the territory of modern India. At the head of each such state was a raja, whose power was based on

From the book Treasures of Ancient Wisdom author Marinina A. V.

Chapter III The Philosophy of the Slave Owning Society of Greece and Rome Ancient philosophy arose in the Greek city-states ("polises") at the turn of the 7th-6th centuries. BC e. first on the western coast of Asia Minor (in Ionia), then in the Greek cities of southern Italy, in coastal

From the book Secret Knowledge. Secrets of the Western Esoteric Tradition author Wallace-Murphy Tim

Sayings of the thinkers of Ancient Greece Anaxagoras 500-428. BC e. Ancient Greek philosopher, the first professional teacher of philosophy. He was the first to reject the divine nature of the heavenly bodies and gave a physical justification for solar eclipses. Nothing can be completely

From the book Philosophy: lecture notes author Shevchuk Denis Alexandrovich

Chapter 5 The Glory of Ancient Greece and the Power of Rome Abstraction, logic, deliberate choice and ingenuity, mathematics, art, the calculated perception of space and duration, the anxieties and dreams of love... All this activity of the inner life is nothing but

From the book History of World Culture author Gorelov Anatoly Alekseevich

1. Philosophy in Ancient India Philosophical ideas in Ancient India begin to take shape around the second millennium BC. Humanity does not know earlier examples. In our time, they have become known thanks to ancient Indian literary monuments under the general

From the book The Secret Meaning of Life. Volume 1 author Livraga Jorge Angel

3. Philosophy in Ancient Greece European and a significant part of modern world civilization are directly or indirectly a product of ancient Greek culture, the most important part of which is philosophy. Given this paradigm, our attitude towards ancient Greek

From the book Comparative Theology. Book 2 author Team of authors

5. Philosophy in Ancient Japan The Japanese imprint of Zen Buddhism in samurai life. One day, a monk came to the master to find out where the entrance to the path of truth is ... The master asked him: do you hear the murmuring of the stream? “I hear,” the monk replied. “The entrance is here,” he said.

From the book Philosophy of Law. Tutorial author Kalnaya I. I.

The history of ancient Greece The emergence of maritime civilizations marks a new stage in the evolution of mankind.

From the author's book

Philosophy of Ancient Greece Several hearths ignited almost simultaneously and, apparently, independently of each other, but only in one of them did the flame of reason and creative burning achieve what deserved the name of philosophy. In addition to the general reasons that took place in all

From the author's book

The Art of Ancient Greece BC e. The fundamental difference from all previous alphabets is that letters appeared in it to denote vowel sounds, that is, it was the Greeks who created

From the author's book

From the author's book

From the author's book

§ 3. The Genesis of the Legal Culture of Ancient Greece Starting from the 10th century BC. the ancient Greeks formed a single nationality - the Hellenes, and the entire sum of the inhabited places in the form of policies - acquires a single name Hellas. A fairly homogeneous public consciousness is being formed on the basis of

abstract

The place and role of ancient Greek philosophy in world religion


Introduction


Religious ideas and philosophical views of the ancient Greeks played a key role in their public and private life and thus had a huge impact on the formation of all ancient and subsequent world culture. Therefore, the study of the religious traditions and philosophical thought of Ancient Greece is of great importance - it allows us to understand much better both the past and the present of mankind.

It is not advisable to separate ancient religion from philosophy, since already in the earliest beliefs of the ancient Hellenes, the rudiments of philosophical thinking, prototypes of ideas about the universal laws of nature, society and thinking, are visible. And, on the other hand, many prominent philosophers of Hellas not only paid great attention to theological issues, but created teachings that differed little from religious ones. Moreover, their students often placed their Teachers on a par with other Gods (as did the students of Anaxagoras, Plato, Epicurus and some others) or even above all the Deities (as the Pythagoreans did, arguing "Reasonable beings are divided into humanoid, godlike and Pythagorean". Apparently, it was no coincidence that B. Russell called philosophy something in between religion and science.

Naturally, in addition to the achievements that have become the "golden fund" of human civilization, the ancient culture of Hellas had its own unique features that distinguish ancient Greek religion and philosophy from similar worldviews of other times and peoples. However, the "universal and particular" were very closely intertwined in reality, and therefore this report is also considered in a comprehensive manner.

And the biggest difficulty facing the speaker is the huge number of ancient and modern sources that reflect the religion and philosophy of Ancient Greece. Unfortunately, any report on this topic has to be limited to only the most general characteristics and a very small number of striking examples.

The purpose of the work is to study the place and role of ancient Greek philosophy in world religion

Examining Philosophers' Views on Religion

Studying the Essence of World Religions

Analysis of the role of ancient Greek philosophy in the formation of religions.


1. Prerequisites for the emergence of religion in human culture

culture religion philosophy greek

Turning to the consideration of religion, it is necessary to be aware of the specifics of its philosophical analysis, which differs from the approaches of specific religious disciplines. Religion is interested in philosophy as one of the forms of value attitude to the world, which has deep roots in the generic nature of man and satisfies his existential needs. The significance of religion for humanity has been and remains enormous, and no philosopher has the right to ignore it.

One of the most difficult problems of the philosophy of religion is to determine the essence of the phenomenon of religion and the place of religious consciousness among other forms of a person's spiritual orientation in the world. Let's start our consideration of this problem with an analysis of the similarities and differences between religion and science, religion and art, religion and morality.

Many of the experts are convinced of the impossibility of such a universal definition of religion, which would cover the whole variety of specific forms and types of religious beliefs. For example, the “epistemological” approach to religion, which considers its main feature to be faith, which is not subject to rational analysis and verification for truth, faces considerable difficulties when trying to distinguish religious beliefs proper from similar ideological phenomena (such as uncritical belief in communism, national superiority and etc.). Similar difficulties are caused by the widespread idea of ​​religion as a system of worldview (and institutional behavior associated with it), based on the belief in the existence of God (or gods) - the highest otherworldly supernatural force that created the world and man in it. Many scholars believe that this approach does not take into account the experience of religious movements (for example, Confucianism or Buddhism), which completely “get along” without a god in the Christian or Muslim sense of it.

Most experts associate the phenomenon of religion with a special form of human experience, the same for all varieties of religion - faith in the sacred, sacred. Ideas about the sacred differ among different peoples. In the early stages of the development of religion, they coincide with the idea of ​​the unusual, which does not fit into the normal course of things, and only later acquire ethical characteristics and become ideas of the absolute good, truth, and beauty.

Whatever the differences in the definition of the concept of religion, all researchers agree that it performs the most important functions in public life. For individual human individuals, according to M. Yinger, religion becomes a means of solving the "last, final" problems of life, acts as a "refusal to capitulate before death." “Religious existence includes a person’s belief that evil, pain, destruction and death, injustice and lack of rights are not accidental, but fundamental conditions of life and that there are still forces and actions (sacred) thanks to which a person is able to overcome evil in in all his guises."

For a society taken as a whole, religion acts as a powerful means of social integration, rallying people, since common beliefs give the highest meaning to their activities. In social terms, religion is realized as a special public institution - the church; at the first stages - simply as an association of believers, later (in almost all religions) - as a clerical structure that unites persons who are especially initiated into sacred secrets and act as a kind of "intermediary" between the object of faith and people.

Of course, not all philosophers and sociologists positively assessed the role of religion in human culture. K. Marx's attitude to religion is known as a distorted form of consciousness, which contributes to the exploitation of the masses. He characterized it as "the opium of the people" and "the sigh of the oppressed creature." 3. Freud also had a negative attitude towards religion, considering it as a peculiar disease of society, as a form of drug intoxication. Many thinkers, guided primarily by the ideals of the Enlightenment, were convinced of the temporary nature of religious beliefs, believing that religion would certainly fall under the blows of developing science. The decline of religion in the XIX-XX centuries. seemed to many a symptom of her impending doom. The 20th century, however, reaffirmed the stability of the religious value system. The main thing was realized - religion cannot be considered as an alternative to science and a "relic" of social consciousness.

Consider the causes of religion and the specifics of its early forms.

Animism is a system of views based on the personification of natural phenomena and endowing them with the properties and abilities of a person. “Considering the character and essence of the great polytheistic gods, to whom the most extensive activity in the universe is attributed, we will see that these powerful beings are formed after the model of the human soul. We will see that their feelings and sympathies, their character and habits, their will and actions, even their very image and material structure, despite all exaggerations and adaptations, contain features that are largely borrowed from the human soul. belief independent life liberated from the body shell of the soul gives rise to faith in the possibility of contact with dead souls. This is based on the peculiarity of primitive thinking, associated with the indistinguishability of the objective, that which is outside of man, and the subjective, that which is the product of his mind. So, for example, the images seen by a person in a dream were perceived as real as the world around him, and both were equally significant. Therefore, communication in a dream with dead or absent people was perceived in the same way as meeting with the living. At the same time, the fear of ghosts, i.e. disembodied shadows of the souls of dead people, gives rise to a whole system of protective rites (during the funeral rite - a special procedure for taking the body out of the house, the position of the body during burial, the very fact of compulsory burial, funeral rites, etc.). It was believed that especially often and unbidden are the ghosts of those souls whose bodies were not buried according to custom, as well as the souls of suicides or those who were forcibly killed. Animistic ideas in one form or another are present in all religions.

Totemism is a system of primitive ideas based on the belief in a supernatural relationship between a group of people (genus) and totems, which can be any animals or plants, less often natural phenomena and inanimate objects. In addition to common totems for the whole family, primitive people had individual totems. Totemistic representations underlie all myths and fairy tales, and totems as special ritual objects are present in developed religions.

Fetishism - belief in the supernatural properties of certain objects (fetishes), which could be anything - from a stone unusual shape, a piece of wood or part of an animal, to an image in the form of a statuette (idol). S.A. Tokarev notes that fetishism, apparently, arises as a form of "individualization of religion" and is associated with the collapse of old tribal ties. “An individual, feeling insufficiently protected by the tribal team and its patrons, seeks support for himself in the world of mysterious forces.” It is no coincidence that talismans and amulets appear among fetishes - items to be worn on the body. They were supposed to perform protective functions. The use of these items was often accompanied by various spells. Gradually, the original meaning of the talisman is forgotten and it turns into an ornament.

Magic - primitive ideas about the possibility of supernatural influence of evil or good forces on other people, livestock, housing, etc. At the core of faith in magical powers and means lies the ability of human consciousness to associate, which allows you to combine in thinking things that are incompatible in reality. As a result, a system of fictional connections and patterns is created, with the help of which a person tries to build his relationship with the world of spirits in the same way as he builds his relationship with the real world.

Magical knowledge is secret. Magical action has always been performed only by specially dedicated people. Therefore, the effectiveness of magical actions and spells was determined only by the result, i.e. hindsight, and in the event of a negative result, one could always refer to the strong opposition of the spirits.

Magic as a means of practical impact on the world is associated with specific forms of human life. Usually magic is divided into economic, medical (white) and harmful (black). According to J. Fraser, magic can be imitative. In this case, the impact on the real object is carried out by manipulating its image. Contagious magic is carried out by complicity, and magical manipulation is carried out over parts of a person’s clothing or body.

In its refined, scientific form, magic is a special section of the occult, acting as a means of linking the spiritual and real worlds through appeal to astral forces. Despite the fact that a number of religions do not approve of magic and witchcraft, elements of magical actions and rituals are present in filmed form in all religions.


. World religions and ancient Greek philosophy


World religions represent a higher stage in the development of religious consciousness, when individual religions acquire a supranational character, opening up to representatives of different peoples, different cultures and languages. Fellow believers act as a single whole, in which there is "neither Greek nor Jew."

The oldest world religion is Buddhism, which arose in the IV-V centuries. The number of people practicing this religion today is several hundred million. According to ancient legends, the founder of this religion is the Indian prince Siddhartha Gautama, who lived in the 5th century BC. BC. and received the name Buddha (enlightened, enlightened).

The basis of Buddhism is a moral teaching, the purpose of which is to make a person perfect. Initially, the moral precepts of Buddhism are built in a negative form (which is typical for all early religions) and are of a prohibitive nature: do not kill, do not take someone else's property, etc. For those striving for perfection, these commandments acquire an absolute character. Thus, the prohibition of murder extends to all living things, and the prohibition of adultery comes to the requirement of complete chastity, and so on. Following the teachings of the Buddha, a person, having passed all the stages of perfection (meditation, yoga), plunges into nirvana - non-existence. He should not count on the gods, but only on himself: even the Buddha does not save anyone personally, but only indicates the path of salvation.

Buddhism is divided into two currents. Theravada (small vehicle) is a more rigid version of Buddhism, based on the strictest observance of prohibitions. There is no concept of God as a being here. Mahayana (great chariot) - classic version world religion with its attributes. If the first variety is available only to a few, the elite, then the second is designed for ordinary people. In this variety there is a god, in it there is also a cult of many buddhas.

In Tibet, Buddhism develops as Tantrism, in which the supreme being Adibuddha stands out and all buddhas are divided into three categories: human, contemplative and formless. Here, special importance is attached to magic and spells, through which you can "shorten" the path to nirvana.

Christianity is one of the most widespread religions today, more than a billion people are its adherents, i.e. approximately 20% of the world's population.

At the center of Christian doctrine is the God-Man Jesus Christ. The main book is the Bible - the Old Testament and New Testament, which presents the life and sufferings of Christ, his sermons and deeds; legends about the deeds of the holy apostles and their messages, as well as

Revelation of St. John the Theologian with his picture of the Last Judgment, which awaits humanity.

Christianity originally emerged as a reformed Judaism, as the religion of the ancient Jews adapted to the wider social context. The elimination of some elements of Judaism that were unpopular among other peoples (ceremonies of circumcision, eating, the idea of ​​the Jewish people chosen by God, the laws of Moses) caused an influx of pagans and converted Jews into Christian communities. Many of these communities, widely spread throughout the territory of the Roman Empire, were united by the idea of ​​a universal church. Early Christianity was characterized by a refusal to participate in political life and government, the preaching of ascetic ethics. The attractive aspects of Christianity were universalism, monotheism, the equality of all believers before God, the idea of ​​the cleansing sacrifice of Christ, faith in retribution in the afterlife, the idea of ​​resurrection.

Before the beginning of the 4th c. there is a sharp controversy with Greek philosophers - Epicureans, Stoics, Neoplatonists, Gnostics. Christianity is opposed by a state worldview based on the dominant pagan religion and on a picture of the world developed within the framework of philosophy. At this time, the apostles, representatives of the Alexandrian school and the first apologists come out in defense of the Christian doctrine: Philo of Alexandria, Justin Martyr, Tatian, Clement, Origen. An acute struggle unfolded over many philosophical and theological problems. The key question was the relationship between philosophy and Christianity, or reason and faith.

Logically, three points of view are possible here: 1) identification of philosophy and faith, 2) philosophy outside of faith and against it, 3) philosophy within the framework of faith. A philosophy that does not notice the two thousand year history of Christianity or deliberately ignores it is theoretically impossible, doomed to failure in advance. It is impossible at the present time to determine morality, justice, good, evil, the development and formation of European statehood and culture without taking into account the historical influence of Christianity on the life of human society.

As for Greek philosophy, possible models its relationship with Christianity is as follows: 1) the Bible both historically and logically precedes Greek philosophy, the Bible contains all the philosophical ideas of the Greeks; 2) Christian teaching inherits Greek philosophy and 3) a synthetic point of view, “according to which the Jews were enlightened through the Law and the prophets, while the Greeks were enlightened, albeit to a lesser extent, through philosophy. The law and the prophets, on the one hand, and philosophy, on the other, anticipated the gospel”; Greek philosophy paved the way for the perception of Christian truths, provided a categorical and logical apparatus for interpreting and substantiating a new religious faith.

The first point of view is theoretically untenable. It is no coincidence that the reaction of the Stoics and Epicureans to Paul's speeches in the Areopagus (the highest body of judicial and political power) in Athens was more than eloquent. While he was talking about God, they listened to him, but as soon as he started talking about the resurrection from the dead, he was interrupted. In the "Acts of the Apostles" we read that, having heard about the resurrection from the dead, some began to mock, others said: "We will listen to you about these arguments another time." So Paul had to leave the meeting

According to the second point of view, we will give an interpretation of the famous Orthodox theologian V.V. Zenkovsky. According to him, Christianity inherits the Greek philosophy in the Plotinian interpretation, which is a kind of theology.

In general, there is no pure philosophy independent of the Logos interpreted in the Christian sense - reason, creative human spirit and integral being. The emergence of the epistemological dualism of faith and knowledge is explained by the need to substantiate Christian teaching. Western Christianity could not, for example, fully accept Aristotle because he denied individual immortality and recognized the infinity of the Cosmos, which contradicted the Christian idea of ​​creation, which presupposes an initial moment of time. In the East, the Aristotelian doctrine was accepted with the inclusion of elements of Platonism and Neoplatonism in it. In theology, the idea arises to separate purely philosophical concepts from theological ones - an idea that turned out to be fatal for the fate of Christian culture. This can be illustrated by the following examples.

Thomas Aquinas divided faith and knowledge, allocating to knowledge the entire area subject to natural reason. But this is, as it were, the lowest sphere of knowledge. Above it is the sphere of religious knowledge, based on the highest source - Revelation. Harmonious cooperation is established between the designated two spheres of knowledge. What is taken from the sphere of natural reason and does not correspond to religious postulates must be explained from the point of view of religious faith. The consistent implementation of the concept of Aquinas leads to a complete separation of philosophy from faith. The expressions "Christian philosophy" or "philosophy of religion" are meaningless from this position (as well as the concept of "Christian mathematics").

According to some (usually Orthodox) modern theologians, after Aquinas in the 13th-16th centuries. there was a "tragic" separation from the Church (secularization) of various spheres of culture: law, philosophy, science. The Church is losing authority and, most importantly, power. Luther and Calvin completely separated the Church from culture. The dualism proclaimed in theory has been embodied in practice in independent institutions of public life, relations between which are established in a similar way. diplomatic relations between different states.

After the separation of philosophy from religion and the church, numerous attempts to build “new” religions on philosophical principles arise: “the system of reasonable Christianity” (purified from irrational moments; everything tragic, bloody and terrible that was associated with Christianity is sent to the past under the name “old Christianity"); religion within the boundaries of reason (Kant); religion as a function of the human spirit, purifying and morally elevating it (Schleiermacher), etc. These attempts come from the camp of philosophers and are aimed at restoring the religious and moral principle in human life. This is the path from secularized philosophy to "authentic" religion as the basis of moral feeling. On the other hand, there is a reverse movement from religion to its philosophical principles.

By the 4th century Christianity ideologically strengthened, and after the decree of Emperor Constantine in 311 on the freedom of Christian religion and the cessation of persecution of Christians, theological disputes are transferred into Christianity, the most significant philosophical concepts and ideas (Aristotle, Plato, Neoplatonists) are adapted to the needs of substantiating Christian doctrine. Christianity becomes the officially recognized religion of the Roman Empire. A little more time will pass and the Nicene Council in 325 will adopt the final formulation of the main dogma of Christianity - the creed - the Trinity: God is one in essence, but trinity in persons (hypostases). This is God the Father, God the Son, God the Holy Spirit - all three persons are attributed the same divine properties (wisdom, eternity, goodness, holiness, etc.), but they have individual differences. God the Father is not born and does not come from other persons of the trinity (absolute origin), God the Son (Logos, the Word - the semantic principle) is eternally born from God the Father, God the Spirit (the life-giving principle) comes from God the Father.

Closely connected with the trinity is another fundamental issue of Christian doctrine: the Christological problem, i.e. the problem of understanding the nature of Jesus Christ, namely, how the divine and human principles are combined in him. One of the influential Christian currents - Nestorianism - distinguishes between the divine and human natures of Christ and does not allow them to merge. Jesus, in the understanding of the Nestorians, is neither God nor a god-man, but a mortal into whom the Holy Spirit has entered. Another trend - the Monophysites - considers Jesus to be God, rejecting the presence of human nature in him. In 431, the Council of Ephesus condemned Nestorianism, and in 451, the Council of Chalcedon established the formulation of the unity of two equal principles in Christ - divine and human. Now each person must bear his own cross. Through suffering, humility and humility, he must overcome evil (the concept of non-resistance to evil by force). The ideas of the Last Judgment, heavenly retribution and the Kingdom of God formed the basis of Christian morality, Christian utopian socialism. Christian rites directly introduce the divine principles into human life.

The influence of Platonism on Christian thought is most clearly manifested by Dionysius the Areopagite (approximately the 5th-6th centuries). He formulated the foundations of apophatic (negative) theology. Affirmative judgments about God, and hence his knowledge, are only a reflection of the divine light in creations. The hierarchy and harmony of the earthly structure corresponds to the divine plan. We can say a lot about the visible and intelligible, we can express a lot in thought and word. But since God surpasses everything created by him and is the highest being, it is better to keep silent about him. “In Mystical Theology we read: “The Good Cause of all things can be expressed in words by many and few, but also by the total and absolute absence of words. In fact, there are no words or understanding to express it, for it is placed above all, and if it is, it is the one who has overcome everything impure and pure, having surpassed the sacred peaks in the ascent, leaving behind all the divine luminaries and invocative sounds, all words and reasoning, penetrating through all the foggy veils to where, as the Scripture says, He who is above all reigns.

The justification of the Christian worldview from a rational position using elements of logic was given by John Scotus Eriugena (c. 810 - c. 877). He was greatly influenced by the writings of pseudo-Dionysius, which he first translated into Latin. Following pseudo-Dionysius, Eriugena believes that the simultaneous acceptance of affirmative and negative judgments about the divine essence is only an apparent contradiction, which is removed in the divine essence itself. If someone claims that "God exists" - this is just an expression of admiration for the Creator of a being hierarchically lower in relation to him. The judgment "God does not exist" can also be accepted, but in a different sense: we make such a judgment because God is rationally incomprehensible to us, and his attributes cannot be expressed in words.

The modern historian of medieval philosophy F. Copleston points out the discrepancy between the Christian teaching and its philosophical interpretation.

But most of all, Anselm of Canterbury became famous for his a priori proof of the existence of God, which was based on the famous ontological argument: "God surpasses everything conceivable in greatness and wisdom." Therefore, any attempt to talk about the non-existence of God implies that the speaker has already imagined in his mind a being superior to God, which contradicts the original argument, i.e. the statement "God does not exist" is false, so we have to admit the truth of the statement "God exists". Such a proof deduces from the idea of ​​God his existence, initially identifying the idea of ​​God with its real existence. Of course, if the premises are true, then the course of the proof itself does not raise any objections. Later such a proof was rejected by Thomas Aquinas (and therefore not accepted by most theologians), but revived by Descartes and Leibniz, further refuted by Kant and discussed to this day. “It is clear that evidence with such a glorious history is worthy of respect, whether it is valid or not,” notes Bertrand Russell, and further explains: “The crux of the matter is this. Is there something of which we can form a mental representation, for which (this something), the mere fact that we can form a mental representation of it, is proof of existence outside our thoughts? Every philosopher would like to answer such a question in the affirmative, for it is the business of the philosopher to attain knowledge of facts about the world not so much by observation as by thought. If such an answer is correct, then we can build a bridge from pure thought to facts;

if it's wrong, we can't. In this general form, Plato uses a kind of ontological proof to confirm the objective reality of ideas. But before Anselm, no one formulated this proof in its naked logical purity. After the Councils of Ephesus and Chalcedon, the role of Christianity in public life is growing more and more, it is slowly but steadily turning from the officially recognized into the dominant religion of the Roman Empire. But hard times are coming for internal church life, because in fact the decisions of these councils prepared the ground for the gradual (V-VII centuries) dissociation from the Roman church of Eastern Christians (Nestorians, Monophysites) and at a later time (1054) led to a split of Christianity into the western and eastern churches, however, here political reasons were already added to the doctrinal differences (the reform of Gregory VII and, in this regard, the unwillingness of the East, and in particular Holy Russia, to submit to the one-man command of the Pope). The doctrinal differences were as follows:

the dogma of the descent of the Holy Spirit (in the Roman Catholic Church, the descent of the Spirit from God the Father and God the Son is recognized, in the Greek Orthodox Church - only from God the Father);

the refusal of the Eastern Church from the practice of indulgences - the paid liberation of a person from his sins;

the Catholic doctrine of purgatory, into which the souls of dead Christians fall, who can then go to heaven, including thanks to prayers offered for them on earth; a vow of celibacy for priests in Catholicism; the dogma of the infallibility of the Pope in matters of faith; recognition as a source of faith for Catholics, in addition to the Holy Scriptures, also Tradition - the totality of the decrees of all councils, sayings, decrees of the popes and the works of the church fathers.

In addition, some ritual differences were established, including the use of the Latin language in Catholic worship. After the 8th century The Orthodox Church no longer participated in the Ecumenical Councils. She invariably adheres to the doctrinal provisions that were adopted at the first two Ecumenical Councils - Nicaea and Chalcedon. These provisions include ideas about divine creation, about the trinity, the Christological problem, the dogma of baptism and the doctrine of the afterlife. Believers are required to know by heart the Creed and the ability to perform it in chorus. Recently, much attention has been paid in Orthodoxy to rational proofs of the main provisions of the dogma, the idea of ​​a connection between faith and knowledge, science and religion has been promoted.

In most countries, the Orthodox Church is separated from the state. Catholicism has always sought to become the state religion, therefore it combined the desire to unite the spiritual and secular authorities. The main Catholic church hierarchs are appointed by the Pope, who has great authority.

In the XVI century. as a result of the powerful movement of the Reformation, a split of Catholicism occurs, Protestantism arises. He recognizes the Holy Scriptures as the only source of faith, declares the principle of the priesthood of all believers (the church is preserved for the performance of the cult and especially important rites), introduces worship on mother tongue believers (the Bible is translated into national languages). Protestantism defended the principle of salvation by personal faith, regardless of specific (good or evil) deeds and recognized the independence of the state in relation to the church. By reducing the importance of rituals, Protestantism increased the importance of intrapersonal spiritual communication with God and gave believers freedom in interpreting the Bible.

Already in the XVI century. such varieties of Protestantism as Lutheranism, Calvinism and Anglicanism are formed. Lutheranism was originally mainly spread in Germany, Austria and Scandinavian countries, Calvinism - in Switzerland, France and Hungary, Anglicanism - in England and Scotland.

Islam, the third world religion, originated in the 7th century and was founded by Muhammad. This religion is practiced by Arabic-speaking peoples, as well as residents of North Africa and most of Asia. The main book of Islam is the Koran, which is a collection of sayings and teachings of Muhammad.

The system of dogmas of Islam is built on the absolute faith in Allah as the only god, whose prophet was Muhammad. It is recognized that God sent other prophets to people, but Mohammed is higher than them. The main rites of Islam include daily prayer five times, washing before it, paying a tax for the poor, an annual fast, and making a pilgrimage to Mecca at least once in a lifetime. Like other religions, Islam is a certain system of moral norms. The Qur'an formulates the moral commandments that a person must follow in his life.


Conclusion


Religion is one of the most common forms of social consciousness, that is, such a spiritual formation that reflects social life, the existing world - nature and society. Religion can be defined as a system of views of a person and actions arising from these views in relation to what seems to a person to be supernatural, going beyond the usual. As a rule, religion is the belief in the existence of supernatural forces and beings embodied in the images of gods, spirits, etc.

The word "religion" itself comes from the Latin language and is derived from the verb "religare" - "to bind", "to unite". There are many definitions of religion. They can be divided into two groups: theological and secular (philosophical and scientific). In most cases, theologians define religion as a person's experience of the presence of the divine principle in the world and the desire to unite with this principle. According to the Protestant theologian Rudolf Otto (1869-1937), religion is the perception of the sacred, "numinous" existing in the world. The study of religion by philosophy begins in antiquity.

Throughout the existence of philosophy, many attempts have been made to define the phenomenon of religion. Moreover, philosophers tried to connect such a definition with the philosophical systems put forward by them. So, I. Kant (1724-1804) in his work "The Dispute of the Faculties" argued that religion has the same functions as morality. From the point of view of I. Kant, religion is “the totality of all our duties in general as the commands of God ... Religion is no different from morality in its content, i.e. object, because it concerns duty in general... Religion is the legislation of reason, designed to give morality influence on the human will for the fulfillment by man of his every duty with the help of the idea of ​​​​God created by reason itself. The difference between religion and morality is, according to Kant, only formal. Kant concludes that "there are no different religions, there are only different kinds faith in divine revelation. Indeed, religion is very important as a regulator of people's behavior, it was within the framework of religious doctrines that the first ethical codes were drawn up (10 commandments of Moses, etc.), which set moral guidelines for people and brought order to the functioning of society and building relationships between people. From the point of view of G. Hegel (1770-1831), religion is one of the forms of the absolute spirit, more perfect than art, but less perfect than philosophy. Hegel argued that religion and philosophy are extremely close to each other.

In religion and philosophy, Hegel recognizes the existence of a common content - thinking about the world, the absolute beginning, the destiny of man. Religion and philosophy are two languages ​​that speak about the same subjects. Religion, according to Hegel, speaks in the language of feelings and ideas, while philosophy operates in the language of specific concepts. In religion, the world spirit that has reached the stage of human consciousness represents itself, and in philosophy it cognizes itself. In philosophy, especially in its materialistic teachings, the "enlightenment" point of view on religion has been popular for many centuries. According to her, religion is the result of people's lack of correct knowledge about the world, their ignorance. As a result, people explain everything they do not understand in a fantastic way, inventing supernatural beings that supposedly control the entire universe and influence people's lives. According to the supporters of the "enlightenment" point of view, progress scientific knowledge will be able to dispel the darkness of ignorance, and freed from superstitions and delusions, the minds of people will not need religion. Representatives of this point of view include thinkers of different historical eras: from Epicurus and Lucretius in antiquity to Bertrand Russell in the 20th century. This point of view became especially widespread in the 18th century - the century of the Enlightenment (F. Voltaire, D. Diderot, P. Holbach, etc.). Also in philosophy, a point of view is quite seriously presented, stating that religion (primarily in the images of the gods) reflects the essential features of a person. Let us recall the thought put forward as early as the 6th century. BC. Xenophanes: people create gods in their own image and likeness, endowing them with the features of their physical appearance and character.


Bibliography


1.Anthology of world philosophy. In 4 vols. M., 1969-1972.

2.Gaidenko P.P. On the Subject of Religious Philosophy // Social Sciences and Modernity. 2006. No. 1.

.Gaidenko P.P. The nature of the religious worldview // Questions of Philosophy. 2005. No. 5.

.Garin I. What is philosophy. What is truth? // M., 2001.

.Hegel G. Philosophy of Religion: In 2 vols. M., 2006. Vol. 1.

.Hegel G. Encyclopedia of Philosophical Sciences: In 3 volumes. M., 2004. V.1.

.Gogotishvili L.A. Losev, Hesychasm and Platonism // Beginnings, 2004. No. 1. M., 1994.

.Ilyin I.A. Philosophy and life. // At the turning point. Philosophy and worldview. M., 2000.

.Kuraev A. (deacon). Christian philosophy and pantheism. M., 2007.

.Lobkovits N. Christianity and Culture // Questions of Philosophy. 2003. No. 1.

.Lobovnik B.A. Religious consciousness and its features. Kyiv, 2006.

.Oizerman T.I. Problems of historical and philosophical science. M., 2009.

.Samygin S.I., Nechipurenko V.A. Religious experience (socio-psychological dimensions). Rostov-on-Don, 2005;

.Samygin S.I., Nechipurenko V.A., Polonskaya I.N. Religious studies: sociology and philosophy of religion. Rostov-on-Don, 2006.

.Sventsitsky V. (prot.) Dialogues. M., 2001.

.Reader in Philosophy: Proc. Manual for universities / Ed. ed. V.P. Kokhanovsky, V.P. Yakovlev. Rostov n/a. 2009.

.Yushkevich P.S. On the Essence of Philosophy // At the Break. Philosophy and worldview. M., 2000.

.Yablokov I.N. Religion: essence and phenomena. M., 2002


Tutoring

Need help learning a topic?

Our experts will advise or provide tutoring services on topics of interest to you.
Submit an application indicating the topic right now to find out about the possibility of obtaining a consultation.

CATEGORIES

POPULAR ARTICLES

2022 "mobi-up.ru" - Garden plants. Interesting about flowers. Perennial flowers and shrubs